docs(avaliacoes): register LifeOS evaluation — Discarded (runtime) / Deferred (patterns)

[pvilarim]

Evaluates LifeOS as a candidate layer for the SDD stack — compatibility with OpenSpec, GitNexus and Graphify, plus a workflow comparison against explore → propose → apply → archive.

Decision (split)

Discarded as kit payload / constitutional layer:

• LifeOS installs a user-global harness (~/.claude/CLAUDE.md, appended system prompt, ~16 hooks, ~50 skills) that competes with AGENTS.md for agent authority. No file collision — context and authority collision.
• Its BPE doctrine (RULES/Philosophy.md) explicitly cuts procedural instruction as scaffolding: "would a smarter model make this rule unnecessary? If yes, it is scaffolding, not architecture, and it belongs cut." Applied to this repo, that deletes the A–E Task Classification Protocol and R1.
• Change model does not reconcile: one living ISA.md mutated in place with git as changelog and no archive concept, versus change-as-delta merged into openspec/specs/.
• No pre-code human gate (R7 has no counterpart); LifeOS gates at close, not at entry.
• Its documented install command (curl … | bash) is denied by this repo's own .claude/settings.json.

Deferred as a pattern source — portable with zero runtime dependency:

• Claim-with-falsifier as a task shape (extends sdd-task-patterns)
• Evidence modality table; "should work" banned
• Non-forked reviewer rule (a fork inherits build context and defends its own code)
• Class-sweep; ask-fidelity ledger

Each is a candidate for its own /opsx:propose.

Method note

Sourced from the shipped files — ALGORITHM/v8.17.3.md, RULES/Verification.md, RULES/Philosophy.md, Workflows/Setup.md — not the README, which still describes a phase machine (OBSERVE→…→LEARN, tiers E1–E5) that v8.17.3 explicitly retired: "there is no phase CLI and no station ceremony of any kind."

LIFEOS_SYSTEM_PROMPT.md and the ourlifeos.ai payload were not readable in this environment and are marked [NEEDS VERIFICATION] in the document — the discard rests on an unread constitutional file, and that gap is stated rather than papered over.

Changes

File	Change
doc/avaliacoes/2026-08-11-lifeos.md	New evaluation (house template)
doc/avaliacoes/README.md	Index row
openspec/project.md	Non-goal: no second constitutional layer for agents

Gates (local, pre-push)

• npx --yes @fission-ai/openspec@1.3.1 validate --all --strict → 22 passed, 0 failed
• bash scripts/verify-task-patterns.sh → all verifiable Pattern paths OK (DOCS_SPECS, fail-closed)

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01UMKoP9v8gf2vikc7nvYgDg

---

Generated by Claude Code